Badge Criteria

Scope Type Name Description Badge
Journal Policy Basis Monstrous Journal Lowest acceptance rate, and high APC
Journal Policy Basis Angel Journal High Acceptance rate, and free APC
Journal Policy Basis Shadow Journal Lack of policy informed
Journal Policy Basis Hard Worker Journal Publish more than 50 papers year
Journal Policy Basis Capitalism Copyright owned by journal with all license except nc
Journal Policy Basis Socialism Copyright owned by author with acc by license
Journal Policy Basis Hero Journal Lowest acceptance rate, free APC, copyright owned by author with cc by license
Journal Diversity Basis Top Market Leader 10 Consecutive issues in a row with authors from more than 5 countries
Journal Diversity Basis Middle Market Leader 5 Consecutive consecutive issues in a row with authors from more than 4 countries
Journal Diversity Basis Low Market Leader Have an issue with authors from more than 4 countries
Journal Diversity Basis Top Global Having active editors from more than 5 countries
Journal Diversity Basis Polyglot Accect paper with more than 2 languanges
Journal Diversity Basis Bilingual Accect paper in 2 languanges
Journal Dissemination Basis Seller apprentice Listed in 3 suggestion based bibliometric indexing
Journal Dissemination Basis Salesman king Listed in 5 suggestion based bibliometric indexing
Journal Dissemination Basis Salesman legend Listed in 10 suggestion based bibliometric indexing
Journal Dissemination Basis Indonesian Hero Accredited by INdonesian Government
Journal Customer care basis Smiling editor Official journal mail, and phone number available on journal website
Journal Customer care basis Customer care master Official journal mail, phone number, journal social media account url with chat service available on journal website
Journal Customer care basis Brother in arms Official journal mail, phone number with whatsapp or telegram service, journal social media account url with chat service, live website chatting, available on journal website
Journal Technology basis Perfectionist editor Journal with complete metadata for all published articles
Journal Technology basis Millenials editor Journal with online submission system (OJS, ARIES, Drupal, EJournal, ScholarOne, Evise)
Journal Technology basis Baby Boomers editor Journal with online mail submission system
Journal Technology basis Lazy editor Journal with lack of metadata for all published articles
Journal Technology basis Written in stone There is archive location data on article
Article Metadata awareness basis Metadata madness Complete metadata on article (ISSN, Journal title, article title, publishing date, contributor orcid id, contributor first and surname, article page or number, abstract, references, article url, license information, update or retraction data)
Article Metadata awareness basis Simple metadata Basic metadata on article (ISSN, Journal title, article title, publishing date, contributor orcid id, contributor first and surname, article page or number, abstract)
Article Metadata awareness basis Funder Money There is funder data on article
Article Metadata awareness basis Independent No funder data on article